Learning to Be Dutch
Three years in the Netherlands: a country built by hand, the small shocks of daily life, and what it means to be asked to become like everyone else.
At first glance, the Netherlands looked like home.
Flat green fields cut by water. Gray skies, soft rain, cows standing in it. The climate and much of the ecology are close cousins of western Washington State. I expected to feel at ease.
I didn't. I lived there for three years, and it was some of the hardest culture shock of my life.
A country built by hand
Start with the land, because the Dutch did.
A large part of the Netherlands sits below sea level. Much of it was once sea, marsh or lake, and was drained and diked into polders over centuries. The water boards that manage it are among the oldest governing bodies in the country. Here, managing water is not a job someone else does. It's the reason the place exists.
What they've built on that reclaimed ground is remarkable. The Netherlands is one of the most densely populated countries on earth, and it is also the second-largest exporter of agricultural products in the world by value, behind only the United States. Greenhouses, seed science, dairy, flowers. Very little land, used with great care.
If you want to see what human beings can do with a landscape, go and look. It's a testament to human capacity.
The small things
So the shock wasn't the landscape. It was the small things.
Dutch directness is famous, and it's real. People say exactly what they think, plainly.
Government offices didn't talk to each other. I found myself carrying documents by hand from one office to another, because that was how they got there.
I rented an apartment that came without light fixtures. In the Netherlands, that's normal. Renters bring their own.
And there's a king. I grew up in a country that began by rejecting one, and learned that kings were a thing of fairy tales and history.
The list goes on. None of it is wrong. It's just different, and all of it at once is a lot.
It didn't help that it was already one of the most stressful periods of my life. The systems I expected to work didn't work. When the stakes are that high, every small thing gets heavier.
Inburgering
Then there was inburgering: civic integration. Newcomers from outside the European Union take classes and exams in Dutch language and Dutch society. In plain terms, they teach you how to be Dutch.
I understand some of the reasoning. It's a small, crowded country that runs on shared rules and a shared language. A place that keeps the sea out by working together has reasons to want everyone pulling in the same direction.
But I grew up believing in the melting pot. I know the United States is hardly the melting pot it claims to be. I believed it anyway, for a long time, and I valued the mix of cultures I lived alongside.
Inburgering felt like the opposite. It felt like I had arrived with nothing worth keeping, and that my value would begin once I'd learned to be like everyone else.
That's the part I still struggle with. The Netherlands has a reputation for openness and tolerance. What I experienced felt like tolerance with terms: become like us first, and then you count. A country can ask newcomers to learn its language and its laws. It can't call itself open and then ask them to arrive empty.
I came with every advantage. White, American, educated. If it felt that way to me, I know it is harder for most of the people sitting in those classes.
Where you are
None of this is only a Dutch problem. My own country has its own long list of ways it fails the people who come to it, and I don't get to pretend otherwise.
There is no perfect country. No perfect place.
The Dutch made land out of water, and they keep it dry every day. Nothing about that place was given. It was built, and it is maintained.
Maybe that's the only honest way to hold anywhere. There is just where you are, and what you choose to do with your time in that place.
Keep up to date on RootedNomad Observations
New observations, delivered to your inbox. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.